9 Opinions That Everyone Keeps Getting Wrong About the Amish

The Amish community, known for its traditional lifestyle and strong sense of community, is often misunderstood by the wider world. While many people have an image of the Amish in their mind, it’s likely full of inaccuracies and myths. From their relationship with technology to their dress code, much of what we think we know about the Amish is far from the truth.

This post explores some of the most common opinions about the Amish that everyone keeps getting wrong, blending both the expected and the bizarre. Prepare to have your preconceived notions challenged in the most unexpected ways.

1. Amish and Technology

Many think the Amish shun all technology, but that’s not entirely true. Some Amish communities allow limited use of technology, like mobile phones, for business. This selective adoption helps them maintain economic viability. They may not have electricity in their homes, but Amish entrepreneurs are savvy in using tech to communicate with suppliers.

Interestingly, the allowance varies, with some districts embracing solar panels to power specific equipment. It’s a myth that they’re entirely tech-averse. Instead, they consider technology’s impact on community and spirituality, picking what aligns with their values. So, the notion of the Amish completely rejecting technology is a major misconception.

2. Amish Cuisine

It’s commonly assumed that Amish cuisine is purely traditional, but that’s not the case. While they are famous for hearty meals like meatloaf and pies, some Amish communities have adopted international cuisine. Sushi, surprisingly, has made its way into Amish kitchens, showcasing their culinary curiosity.

The blending of old and new delights Amish palates while staying true to their values of community and home-cooked meals. However, their food remains wholesome, reflecting their agricultural lifestyle. The idea that Amish only eat traditional American food doesn’t account for their subtle embrace of global flavors. Their culinary world is more diverse than one might think.

3. Amish Fashion Sense

The stereotype of the Amish wearing only dull colors is not accurate. While modesty is key, some communities allow brighter hues in their garments, especially for young women. This splash of color often comes as a surprise to outsiders.

The style remains simple, but the choice of color can be daring within their cultural context. Clothing is handmade, often reflecting individual expression while adhering to community guidelines. The belief that Amish fashion is stuck in the past overlooks these subtle evolutions. Amish attire might be more varied than expected while still respecting tradition.

4. Amish and Environmentalism

The Amish are often seen as detached from modern environmental discussions, but they practice sustainable living naturally. Their lifestyle, centered around agriculture and simplicity, aligns with eco-friendly principles.

Some communities actively engage in conversations about renewable energy, like wind turbines, to sustain their simple lifestyle without harming the planet. The notion that the Amish are uninterested in ecology ignores their inherent sustainable practices. They might not brand themselves as environmentalists, but their way of life contributes positively to the planet, challenging the idea that they are indifferent to environmental issues.

5. Amish Music

Music among the Amish is typically considered to be only hymns, yet some young Amish explore beyond this. Despite restrictions, there’s a growing interest in popular music, albeit discreetly.

Teenagers might practice instruments like guitars in hidden corners of barns, reflecting a curiosity about the broader musical world. While community events focus on traditional hymns, the private exploration of new genres shows a dynamic cultural side. The belief that Amish music is limited to religious songs misses this youthful intrigue. Music, though primarily traditional, has hidden layers of modern exploration.

6. Amish in Pop Culture

Pop culture seems worlds apart from Amish life, yet it seeps in more than assumed. Some Amish enjoy popular movies when given the chance, providing entertainment without compromising beliefs.

Media consumption is largely restricted, but occasional glimpses into the world of cinema are not unheard of. This selective viewing reflects curiosity and a desire to understand the world beyond their communities. The idea that the Amish are oblivious to pop culture is not entirely correct. Despite restrictions, they maintain a nuanced engagement with the cultural phenomena around them.

7. Amish and Sports

Sports are not typically associated with the Amish, yet many participate in games for recreation. Basketball is a favorite, often played in barns or open fields.

These activities provide a healthy outlet for physical activity, fostering community bonding. While professional sports are not followed, local games are an integral part of social life. The perception that Amish avoid sports overlooks these community engagements. They might not have teams in major leagues, but sports are a cherished pastime, blending fitness with fellowship in their unique style.

8. Amish and Travel

Traveling beyond their communities is more common among the Amish than assumed. They use modern transportation, like trains and planes, especially for business or family visits.

Some Amish even travel internationally, experiencing different cultures while maintaining their own. This travel expands their worldview, though they remain rooted in their traditions. The belief that Amish never venture far from home misses the practicality of occasional travel. Their journeys are purposeful, reflecting adaptability in a modern world. While they might not travel often, when they do, the experience is meaningful and enriching.

9. Amish and Healthcare

The perception that Amish avoid all modern healthcare is incorrect. While they favor natural remedies, they seek medical help when necessary. Their approach blends traditional wisdom with modern practices.

Community health insurances exist, supporting members in accessing healthcare without relying on government aid. This balance of old and new reflects practicality. They value health, using available resources wisely. The notion that the Amish reject all modern medicine overlooks their nuanced approach to wellness. Their healthcare choices are thoughtful, considering both spiritual beliefs and practical health needs.